GUEST BLOG: Bob Flaws’ Thoughts on the FPD:

The following is copied (with permission) from Bob Flaws’ blog at Blue Poppy Press: Several days ago I posted a blog supporting SIOM’s proposal for an acupuncture only entry-level degree program. As a follow-up to that, I would like to state my opposition to a “first professional doctorate” (FPD) degree if such a degree was the only degree offered by our accredited schools and colleges. There have been discussions of creating the standards for just such a degree within the Accrediting Commission for Acupuncture & Oriental Medicine (ACAOM). Right now, a number of schools offer a post-graduate Doctor of Oriental Medicine (DOM) degree program which students who have graduated from MSAOM programs. Since those programs are completely optional, I support them, at least in principle. (I am somewhat critical of these programs’ curricula and question whether they do create real doctors of Oriental medicine.) However, I am against requiring all entry-level students to take even longer, more expensive programs than currently exist. While I understand that physical therapists have recently adopted an FPD degree, I believe that such a requirement within our profession would lead to even higher rates of graduate failure and less access to acupuncture services for the majority of Americans.

In previous blogs I have addressed some of the issues surrounding the jamming together of acupuncture and Chinese herbal medicine into a single entry-level program. I believe there is a definite difference in the knowledge and practical skills necessary to do acupuncture-moxibustion and Chinese herbal medicine. In Chinese colleges, there are separate degree tracks for these two modalities, and graduates only typically practice one or the other. Further, in China, acupuncture-moxibustion has always been seen as a secondary, adjunctive modality within the larger realm of Chinese medicine as a whole. Nevertheless, acupuncture-moxibustion is incredibly effective clinically, especially for the core group of disorders for which it is primarily used in China. Another unique characteristic of acu-moxibustion (in contradistinction to Chinese herbal medicine) is that a single practitioner can treat several patients at a time, whether in one large room or in several small treatment cubicles. In addition, it is my experience that competent acupuncturists can be trained in a single year (or less). Economically, students who graduate with less debt can afford to charge less money for their services. Since acu-moxa therapy allows for the treatment of multiple patients simultaneously, acu-moxa practitioners can charge less per patient but still make a very comfortable living by seeing more patients, making up in volume for less charge per patient visit.

Larry Gatti, writing for the Community Acupuncture Network (CAN) board of directors on the CAN website says:

“Estimates show a high practitioner failure rate, with somewhere between 50%-80% of new graduates not practicing acupuncture five years after graduation- after having taken out student loans of $40,000 to $150,000 to fund their acupuncture education. While other healthcare professions, such as physical therapy, have changed their entry-level degree status to the doctorate level, there exist actual jobs for physical therapists upon graduation. Jobs also await occupational therapist, nursing, chiropractic and physician assistant graduates. The same is not true for acupuncture graduates, for whom entrepreneurship is the most likely option upon graduating.”

Gatti goes on to say, “CAN maintains that the community acupuncture business model is both the best way to bring acupuncture to the masses with its $15-$40 sliding scale, as well as the most realistic way for graduates to make a living doing acupuncture.” CAN Board President, Andy Wegman, has also stated:

“Acupuncture schools already encumber students with an unrealistic business model, not to mention significant student loan bills. What this adds up to is higher costs for patients, as students try to recoup their losses. The proposed doctoral degree would likely compound this problem, pushing acupuncture even further out of the reach of working and middle class people.”

I very much agree with CAN’s position on the FPD. Back in the 1980s, we made a mistake creating a single educational track for both acu-moxa therapy and Chinese herbal medicine. Now, rather than compounding that mistake by creating an even more time-consuming and expensive FPD, we should be offering more acupuncture only courses, similar to the one recently proposed by SIOM. Especially in these tough economic times (with their many long-term uncertainties), we should not be driving up the hours and, therefore, tuition required for professional entry. I believe we should be training more acupuncture technicians who can bring the benefits of acupuncture-moxibustion to a much broader segment of our society. We are not going to gain the financial rewards nor the social status we desire by simply awarding our graduates a doctoral degree. However, we can earn both of those two things if we really show a large part of our society that acu-moxa therapy is affordable and effective treatment.

–Bob Flaws

Jessica Feltz
Author: Jessica Feltz

<p> I learned about Community Acupuncture while studying at the Midwest College of Oriental Medicine (MCOM) in the Spring of 2006 when Lisa Rohleder's first article about her clinic appeared in Acupuncture Today. Coming from a middle-class background myself, I was the only student in my acupuncture class to have not experienced the healing benefits of this medicine prior to beginning studies at MCOM. I couldn't afford it. And my family couldn't understand what I was doing by investing in an education that they didn't perceive to be financially sustainable. </p> <p> The Community Acupuncture model is a perfect fit for me, balancing social justice and taoist simplicity with the patient's innate ability to heal him/herself (with a few gentle nudges from strategically placed needles). I am grateful every day to have found CAN and the love it brings into my life. I want to share that joy by spreading the message about how we can create a new health care experience in our communities through each of our very small efforts...and how those very small efforts can in turn change the world. </p> I enjoy my two sons, my 4 cats, and big stacks of books.  I own and operate...

Related Articles


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. I am not surprised to that

    I am not surprised to that Bob Flaws has this opinion.  I took distance learning CEU course of his earlier this year about the treatment of infertility whith chinese medicine.

    One of things that really stuck out to me was his assertion “There is no historical precedence for once a week acupuncture!”  I mention it here because I have found it to be very useful statement in educationg patients about the benefit of frequent acupuncture treatments.

    It’s great to see that knowlegdable and influential people in the Western world of TCM are coming on board with breaking down the barriers preventing access to acupuncture care in the west.


  2. Hooray,
    More sane


    More sane acupuncturists. Soon thay’ll outnumber the insane. So, when do we start advocating for the one year entry level?


  3. Using this in a mass Mailing?

    Thank you for posting this, as I do not read BF’s blog.  Is anyone planning on printing it off and mailing it to their own state boards, NCCCCCCCCCAOM, or the AAAAAAAAAACAOM, or the CCCCCCCCCAOM?

    oh yeah, and what about Acupuncture Today?

    Sending enmasse may be a good way to making our  point and being heard. 

    Feedback please, Elizabeth

  4. It seems that some kind of gathering

    needs to maybe start happening in the world of acupuncture.  It seems that Andy Wegman and our CAN Board are starting to have their voices heard in the arena of acupuncture power players.  And many of you have worked and participated in perhaps the greatest splinter in our profession…community acupuncture.

    So instead of waiting for THEM (you know all of those acronyms), why don’t we as a community invite THEM to a group counsel.  Discuss the deteriorating conditions of acupuncture education in terms of lack of opportunity, onerous educational requirements, limited access of Americans and others into our services (but growing due to CAN) and the uselessness of 3rd party reimbursement etc.  Put together a proposal paper & invite position papers to be presented and hash it out….Round 1.

    We are not paying for anyone to come but choose somewhere that is accessible to everyone (hey! how about Minneapolis?), not very expensive accomodations and invite schools, associations, licensing boards, NADA certifiers, and famous acupuncture leaders like Bob Flaws and Macciocia…see what happens.

  5. Agree

    I completely agree with the article. I’m also critical of this problems. It seems to me if you’d like to really know acupuncture you’d better learn from the people who are near to the original sources of it. I believe the best thing is to to China to finish your studying.

  6. Eh.

    While I agree with some of the issues faced. I don’t see the point of it. Acupuncture is a holistic medicine practice. Therefor it stands to reason that any holistic medicine outlet that is looking to expand would be a perfect candidate for those who have their license to practice to try to get a job. Seeing as how a majority of the holistic outlets are also spas. They would be perfect to look into hiring.

  7. wow

    I never thought of it like that. I thought of them as doctors or unlicensed practitioners. Very eye opening. thanks.